• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Sheboygan Pasty Company: Authentic Wisconsin Pasties with Fresh Ingredients and Friendly Service

Sheboygan Pasty Company, nestled in Sheboygan, Wisconsin, serves hearty, authentic pasties that celebrate Midwest comfort food. Known for their flaky, tender crusts and generous fillings—like traditional beef with rutabaga, carrots, and onions or creative blends with bratwurst and cheese—these pasties offer a perfect balance of flavor and texture. Customers praise the fresh, well-cooked meals and friendly, attentive staff, making each visit warm and inviting. Whether grabbing one fresh at their storefront, enjoying them at the Wisconsin State Fair, or ordering frozen to bake at home, Sheboygan Pasty Company delivers satisfying, savory treats that evoke nostalgia and fill you with wholesome comfort.

Sheboygan Pasty Company at a glance

  • Address 811 A Indiana Ave, Sheboygan, WI 53081, United States
  • Phone +1 920-395-2132
  • Restaurant type Restaurant , Frozen food manufacturer .
  • Popular for Lunch , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Sheboygan Pasty Company: Reviews & Ratings

Elizabeth Pope
5

Loved my Thanksgiving Pasty ! Got the last 2 for me and my Husband on our way to Greenbay for tomorrow’s game. Loved the lady who prepared them. She made sure we got gravy on the side to go. We scarfed them while we charged up at the nearby Tesla station. Tasty treats, great comfort food.Fresh food, clean bathrooms.

Bridget H
4

I found this on google maps when searching for some interesting local food. I got the traditional u.p. pasty with beef, rutabaga, carrots and onions. It was exceptional and cooked to perfection. The crust is perfect, it's flavorful and tender without being doughy. With or without gravy, it's delectable. You can also get frozen ones to bake at home. I haven't tried the breakfast pasty yet but, I feel certain that I won't be disappointed. The chocolate "pasty" they sell is made elsewhere but, yummy. The employees offer service with a smile. I only gave it 4 stars because there is no atmosphere. I recommend ordering ahead and getting curbside delivery.

Florence
5

At the Wisconsin State Fair, I got a massive Sheboygan Pasty from their table and it was love at first flaky buttery bite! Inside was bratwurst, potato, onion, and cheese with zero empty space. Even after a whole day of fair food, I still made room for it and I'd do the same on my deathbed! NOTES/TIPS: **Super friendly staff **In the Expo Center at the fair

MistahZ
5

Finally decided to get an order from Sheboygan Pasty Company and I was glad I did! Can't comment on the building or service as I got a delivery order, though the delivery driver was quick and polite! As for the food, I liked it all! Chilli and smaller pasties were very good! The main pasties were scrumptious and filled me up quick! Dessert items were good! My only complaints were the main pasties I got had a texture I did not like and the fudge was not that good but, that's it! Try The Pasty Company, I liked it! Pictures and video are of the food I got!

Jessi F
5

These pasties are delicious! I always loved Rainier’s 4 of a kind, so they continued their good food with the pasties! I will be back! Photos are of the Traditional with gravy.

John Michaels
5

I had the Sheboygan. Great job! Really, REALLY GOOD! I loved the gravy as well! But.... very salty, just the way I like it but maybe not for most.

thisis hybrid
5

Great flavour and generous sizes. A very hearty meal that reminds me of home. Small prices and worth the trip. Found inside a dive bar at the very back hiding away is this special place.

Arlen Brunsvold
4

Pretty local good pasties. Located inside Ranieris Four if a Kind bar.

Location

  • Sheboygan Pasty Company
    Sheboygan Pasty Company
    811 A Indiana Ave, Sheboygan, WI 53081, United States Hotline: +1 920-395-2132

Sheboygan Pasty Company stands as a true gem in Wisconsin’s culinary landscape, offering hearty, handcrafted pasties that capture the very essence of comfort food. Nestled at 811 A Indiana Ave in Sheboygan, this eatery has won the hearts of locals and travelers alike with its flaky, golden crusts and generous fillings. Each pasty boasts a rich medley of fresh ingredients—from traditional beef, rutabaga, carrots, and onions to inventive blends like bratwurst with potato and cheese. The meticulous preparation shines through in every bite, delivering perfectly balanced flavors that are tender without being doughy.

What sets Sheboygan Pasty Company apart is not just the quality of its food but the genuine warmth of its service. Customers like Elizabeth Pope appreciate the thoughtful touches—like gravy served on the side and a staff eager to enhance your experience. Whether you’re grabbing a pasty at the Wisconsin State Fair or picking up a frozen one for home baking, the commitment to freshness and taste is unwavering.

Beyond savory options, the company offers dessert pasties and smaller, flavorful varieties such as chili pasties that satisfy cravings with their boldness. While the chocolate pasty is made elsewhere, it remains a sweet finish to a robust meal. Fast delivery and friendly staff add convenience, making it easy to enjoy these comforting treats wherever you are.

In essence, Sheboygan Pasty Company captures the heart of Midwestern cuisine with every flaky, buttery pasty. It’s more than just a meal—it’s a delicious tradition worth savoring time and again. For those seeking satisfying, expertly crafted pasties with a slice of genuine hospitality, this spot is a must-visit.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Kerbside pickup
    • No-contact delivery
    • Delivery
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • Credit cards